Common Pitfalls to Avoid When Creating a Buy-Sell Agreement

Written by Michael Gray

When it comes to business partnerships, everyone involved wants stability. One way to add in an extra layer of security is through a buy-sell agreement outlining the procedures and actions to be taken in scenarios like a partner’s departure, disability, or death.

However, drafting an effective buy-sell agreement can be a challenging task, with many potential missteps. Lack of thorough planning, missing crucial details, and not considering future changes can lead to serious issues later down the line.

We’re diving into some of the common pitfalls in buy-sell agreements and how you can avoid them to craft an agreement that’s strong, equitable, and ready to safeguard your business interests during uncertain times. Let’s get into it.

What is a Buy-Sell Agreement?

A buy-sell agreement is a legally binding contract between business owners that outlines how a partner’s share of the business will be reassigned if they leave the company due to retirement, death, or disability.

what is a buy-sell agreement

The main goal of a buy-sell agreement is to protect business continuity and prevent conflicts by pre-establishing the terms of business ownership transfer. Life and disability insurance plays a pivotal role in these agreements. They provide the financial means to buy the departing partner’s share, helping the business to continue smoothly without financial strain.

There are several types of buy-sell agreements according to what a business needs. In a cross-purchase agreement, the remaining owners buy the departing owner’s interest. An entity-purchase agreement allows the company itself to purchase the interest. Lastly, a hybrid agreement combines elements of both, offering flexibility in how shares are bought and sold.

Pitfall #1: Inadequate Funding Mechanisms

One of the most common pitfalls with buy-sell agreements is not having enough provision for funding mechanisms. Without proper financial planning, the agreement, despite its well-intentioned clauses, may fail to execute effectively when needed. Not enough funding can quickly leave the business in financial jeopardy, struggling to buy out the other owner’s share and leading to forced liquidation or an unfavorable sale.

The role of life and disability insurance in this context cannot be overstated. These insurance policies provide the necessary liquidity to facilitate the purchase of an outgoing partner’s interest without straining the company’s finances. For example, in the event of a partner’s untimely death or disability, the insurance payout can be used to buy their share to help the business continue with minimal financial disruption.

Consider this: a business partner unexpectedly dies without life insurance. The remaining partners might need to take out loans or dip into business reserves to keep the company running, destabilizing its long-term financial health. But with a life insurance policy designated for this purpose, the buy-sell agreement can be executed smoothly, safeguarding the business’s and the deceased partner’s family’s interests.

Pitfall #2: Outdated Agreement Terms

The business environment is fluid, so it’s usually the case that buy-sell agreements aren’t set in stone and need updating regularly. One common oversight is allowing the terms of the agreement to become outdated, which can lead to significant complications, especially concerning the valuation of the business.

An agreement based on an outdated business valuation might not reflect the company’s current worth, leading to unfair buyouts and potential disputes among partners. If a business has grown significantly since the last valuation, the departing partner or their beneficiaries might receive less than the fair market value of their share. Conversely, if the business value has decreased, the remaining partners might overpay to buy out the partner.

This has a simple fix: review and update your buy-sell agreement regularly. A good practice is to reevaluate the agreement annually or whenever there is a significant change in the business, such as a major increase in revenue, the introduction of new products or services, or a change in ownership structure.

Pitfall #3: Ignoring Tax Implications

Neglecting the tax implications is a critical pitfall in structuring a buy-sell agreement. A poorly configured agreement can lead to unexpected tax burdens for the business or the individual partners.

If the agreement isn’t structured properly, the proceeds from a life insurance policy meant to fund a buyout might mostly go to the tax man. To mitigate these tax risks, it’s essential to involve tax professionals in drafting and reviewing the agreement. Tax experts can provide valuable insights into structuring the agreement to minimize tax liabilities. They can navigate complex tax regulations and suggest strategies that align with the latest tax laws.

Regularly consulting tax experts ensures the buy-sell agreement remains tax-efficient and compliant during its lifespan, protecting all involved parties from unforeseen tax issues.

Pitfall #4: Lack of Clarity and Detail

One of the biggest challenges with an effective buy-sell agreement is clearly communicating the terms. A common pitfall that can lead to serious disputes and misunderstandings is including vague terminology or conditions.

Ambiguity in the agreement can result in different interpretations, leading to conflicts among partners and potentially lengthy legal battles. For instance, unclear definitions of disability or valuation methods can cause disagreements on when and how the agreement should come into effect.

To prevent these hassles, it’s crucial to have every clause in the buy-sell agreement cover the three basics: it needs to be clear, detailed and unambiguous. This includes precise definitions of key terms, specific conditions under which the agreement is activated, and a well-defined process for business valuation and buyout procedures.

A well-drafted buy-sell agreement leaves little room for misinterpretation, safeguarding everyone’s interests and guaranteeing the smooth continuation of the business in the face of unforeseen events.

Final thoughts

Drafting a robust buy-sell agreement requires careful consideration to avoid common pitfalls such as inadequate funding, outdated terms, tax complications, and lack of clarity. By addressing these issues head-on, businesses can ensure a stable and secure future, even in the face of unforeseen events.

For more insights and assistance, don’t hesitate to explore our frequently asked questions section, where we delve deeper into the nuances of buy-sell agreements and offer expert advice to guide you through this critical process.


We work with individuals across the nation to secure the best life insurance rates.

This entry was posted in Blog. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.